Been wearing these 5 days a week for about 18 months, they are still holding up like brand new. I prefer this style attachment rather than the alligator clips which never seem to hold on very long for me. I've never had one of these pop off. A couple times it felt a little loose where the rubber sqeezes into the clip, but I just pinched it with a pair of pliers and it was nice and tight. I wore the other style during my time in the Marine Corps and these are much easier to use for me in the Y style with just one attachment to the sock. If this pair ever wears out I'll for sure buy another.
I have to roll the shirt hem a few times in order to make the clip tight enough to not constantly fall off. Other than that, it's a fine product. If the clips were super strong, I would be happier.
These shirt stays are heavy duty (nice quality) and work well on every day use with my work shirts.
Does not stay clipped in and will launch when it comes undone