The fabric of your shirts and socks WILL matter--if they are cheaper / thinner materials, they could rip. Mine didn't, but I can tell the clasps but stress on my clothes. Socks definitely stay up! (at an angle, obviously, but you can't tell when the top of the sock is covered by pants). Shirts stay tucked in. If you stretch your arms up, the shirt will come loose--not as loose as without these, but DON'T expect your shirt to stay exactly as-is when you first put them on. I didn't mind the way it looked when loosened--I liked it, actually--but if you're hoping that there will be crisp clean lines no matter how you move, I can't say these will achieve that. I was worried about chaffing when I first put them on, but no chaffing (YAY). I tuned them out fairly soon, but if you're on the more-sensitive side (skin, stimulation, etc)--may want to consider different options. I consistently felt as though something was in my pockets--but no, just the straps under my pants. I'm an NB-F at 5ft 4.5in, and these were fairly easy to adjust. They could easily be adjust for much-shorter-people AND much-taller-people alike. The straps are stretchy, too, so even when fully extended--you still have wiggle room. BEST PART: going to the bathroom is so much faster. You don't have to re-tuck your shirt at ALL, and it's a very (VERY) minimal amount of time to re-adjust once your pants are back up. I'm talking less than 7 seconds to make everything look nice. This alone is my favorite aspect of these, and the precise reason I'll recommend them to everyone. (Although I'm considering looking at 3-shirt-clasps + 1-sock, or 1-shirt + 1-sock clasps to see if those options would reduce the amount of loosening that happens when you move around). The time saved getting out of the bathroom is a game changer for me. 9/10 recommend, and if you don't mind a little loosening-of-the-shirt-when-you-move: 10/10.

Bought these for my son to wear with his dress shirts and they were easy to use and comfortable.

Work well and hardly feel them on, do what they meant to do.

Nice

Keeps my shirts tucked in. TSA pulled me aside twice; no complaints other than that.

Husband uses them. They work well.

I've worn these everyday for a mo th already and they are great!

Love these things. Have bought multiple pairs... they work perfectly.

Love these things. Have bought multiple pairs... they work perfectly.

Questionable quality. Wore them for half a day and noticed around lunch time something was scratching my leg. Took a look and saw the stitching was already coming undone.

I've been wearing these for a few weeks now and I have overall enjoyed their usefulness. My only complaint is the metal parts on the clasps dig into the meat of my leg when setting down. This was fixed using Gorilla Tape around the metal clasps once the right length was set. They tend to become uncomfortable after prolonged use, especially around the calves, so I tend to shift them around a lot after wearing them for many hours.
The rubber grips that attach to your shirt/sock work well and keep the shirt tucked in when walking, sitting, standing, etc. Over all a well developed product that doesn't trace much at all even with fitted trousers.

Fit well, and get me through TSA metal detector with no issue, unlike the metal clip shirt stays. Don't hold quite as well but no total failures.

I use these daily to keep my shirt nice and neat while at work, I work in a casino as a manager and have to look sharp at all times and with these keepers I have had no issues with my shirt looking bad after doing anything.

I’m sensitive to that plastic garment thread (think fishing line) that pokes me or rubs in the same spot over and over. I used my sweater shaver (pill remover) on it and now it’s fine.

I have been using these for a few weeks and I have to say that I am pleasantly surprised. They have held up great, done what they were supposed to do. I was in between this brand and another that was $10 dollars more, save your $10 and get these. Nothing but good to say about them.